Use this checklist to see where claims leak in a small practice — from the front desk through denials, accounts receivable, and credentialing. Mark each item Yes, Partial, or No. There are 25 items. No procedure codes are listed; the point is the process, not a coding manual.
Front desk and eligibility
Catch coverage problems before the visit, not after the denial.
- Insurance is verified before every visit, including coverage dates and plan type.
- Copay, deductible, and referral requirements are checked and collected or noted at check-in.
- Patient demographics and member IDs are matched to the payer’s eligibility response, not copied from an old record.
- Prior authorizations are obtained and logged — including units and date range — before scheduled services that require them.
Coding and charge entry
Speed matters, but only if the claim matches the documentation. This section does not use procedure codes.
- Charges are entered the same day or the next business day after the visit.
- Documentation supports the level of service, the procedures billed, and the units submitted.
- Same-day preventive and problem-focused visits are split only when the note clearly supports both.
- Place of service, rendering provider, and supervising provider (when required) are correct before the claim is built.
Claim submission
A clean claim that goes out fast is the cheapest A/R program you can run.
- Claims are scrubbed for errors before submission, and a person reviews anything the scrub flags.
- Claims go out within 24 hours of charge entry.
- Clearinghouse rejections are corrected the same day they arrive.
- Electronic remittances and payments are posted the day they arrive.
Denials and appeals
Unworked denials become 90-day balances, then write-offs.
- Every denial is categorized by reason and assigned an owner.
- New denials are worked within a set number of business days (for example, 48 hours).
- Appeals include the documentation the payer actually asked for, plus a clear timeline.
- Repeat denial reasons are reviewed monthly and fixed at the source, not only appealed again.
Accounts receivable
Watch the aging mix, not just the headline days-in-A/R number.
- Days in A/R are calculated the same way every month and reviewed with the practice owner.
- The aging report is worked weekly, starting with high-dollar and 90-day-and-older balances.
- Insurance A/R and patient A/R are tracked separately, and patient statements go out on a regular schedule.
- Credits, contractual adjustments, and underpayments are reviewed against contracted rates, not auto-written off.
Payer contracts and credentialing
A visit you cannot bill is a scheduling problem as much as a billing problem.
- Each rendering provider is enrolled and currently credentialed with the practice’s major payers.
- Revalidation, CAQH, and Medicare or Medicaid enrollment dates are tracked before they lapse.
- Fee schedules and contract rates are sampled against payments to catch underpayments.
Reporting
If the owner cannot see the picture, the process will not improve.
- The practice owner receives a monthly report of billed, paid, denied, and aged balances.
- First-pass clean-claim rate and denial rate are tracked over time, with the top denial reasons named.
How to score
Give each item 2 points for Yes, 1 point for Partial, and 0 for No. The maximum score is 50.
- 40–50: The process is in good shape. Use the Partial items as this quarter’s cleanup list, and keep watching days in A/R and your first-pass clean-claim rate.
- 25–39: There are meaningful gaps, often at eligibility, denial follow-up, or aging. Fix the lowest-scoring section first; that is usually where cash is stuck.
- 0–24: The revenue cycle needs a structured reset. Claims, denials, and old A/R are likely competing for the same hours.
Scoring is a conversation starter, not a credential. If you want a second set of eyes, RevWell will review 90 days of claims and send a plain-English report in 5 business days. No PHI is needed to start, and there is no obligation.
Free Billing Assessment